 |
Minutes Archive |
|
|
Board of
Commissioners Minutes
CALHOUN COUNTY
PROCEEDINGS OF THE
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
July 20, 2006
The Regular Session of the Calhoun County Board of
Commissioners convened at 7:00 p.m., Thursday, July 20, 2006 in the
Commissioners' Meeting Room, County Building, Marshall, Michigan.
Roll Call: Present: Comrs. Bolger, Miller, Moore,
Segal, Solis, Strowbridge and Todd.
INVOCATION AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE:
A Moment of Personal Prayer was observed; followed by
the Pledge of Allegiance, led by Comr. Todd.
APPROVAL OF AGENDA:
“Motion by Comr. Segal, supported by Comr. Bolger,
adopt the following: Resolved by the Calhoun County Board of
Commissioners approve the July 20, 2006 agenda as presented.”
Voice Vote: Motion CARRIED
CITIZENS’ TIME:
Mr. Gardy Berezonsky, Marengo Township resident,
recommended the Board limit the length of presentations to ten minutes.
Mr. Berezonsky addressed Agenda Item No. 10.A. (2),
questioning why the Sheriff requires waiver of the county’s purchasing
policy, pointing out that the E*Justice criminal justice information
system agreement was received on June 9, 2006.
ELECTED/APPOINTED COUNTY OFFICIALS’ COMMENTS:
Sheriff Allen Byam reported that the Sheriff
Department has received confirmation that the federal daily inmate
boarding rate will increase from $51.25 per day to $58.14 effective
August 1, 2006. Sheriff Byam stated that he is very pleased with the
efforts of Mr. Summerill and Mr. Bryan and the assistance of Congressman
Schwarz.
Sheriff Byam advised that Mr. Summerill shall
continue to address issues regarding the contract. Sheriff Byam stated
that he believes more can be done and that the Department and the Board
should work together during the budget process as there are a number of
potential projects that could bring in more revenue to Calhoun County.
Sheriff Byam thanked Board members and recognized the efforts of the
Corrections Division staff.
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS:
Senior Millage Renewal Presentation
Senior Services Coordinator Christine Schauer
addressed the upcoming senior millage renewal proposition and what the
millage provides for Calhoun County seniors. Ms. Schauer advised that
the millage provides $2.4 Million to the county per year which is used
to provide services to Calhoun County citizens age 60 and older to
enable them to remain in their homes as long as possible. Ms. Schauer
stated that the proposition is for a five year renewal of 3/4 mil.
Ms. Schauer advised regarding services provided by
the millage; e.g., health, dental, discount prescriptions, personal
emergency response, hospice and respite care, whole person wellness,
home delivered and congregate meals, access services, legal assistance,
guardianship, minor home repairs, transportation, case management and
purchase of in-home services. Ms. Schauer pointed out that without the
millage half of the individuals receiving meals would have to go without
as only 50 percent of the funding for that service is provided by state
funding. Ms. Schauer further advised that one half of those receiving
minor home repairs are Albion residents.
Ms. Schauer continued that over 6,900 seniors receive
services through the Senior Millage Program; and that all of the
services, with the exception of the prescription discount card, are
provided through ten service providers that received $2.1 Million last
year, and $2.3 Million is allocated for this year.
Ms. Schauer advised that the cost of the millage to
the taxpayers equates to $37 a year on a $100,000 home. Ms. Schauer
encouraged Board members to address the millage with their constituents
and remind them to vote on August 8.
PETITIONS AND NEW BUSINESS:
County Administrator/Controller’s Report
June Financial Statements
Interim Finance Director Pam Kline reported that the
June financial statements show a net decrease in the General Fund for
the first six months totaling $2,804,341. Expenditures are pretty even
and close to the 50 percent targeted level, however, the revenues are
considerably less mainly due to collection of property taxes. Ms. Kline
advised that the revenue should be coming in at the end of July or
beginning of August.
Waiver of County Policy No. 405 - Purchasing
County Administrator/Controller Greg Purcell advised
that waiver of the Purchasing Policy is requested to move the E*Justice
Criminal Justice Information System Agreement forward more expeditiously
to gain some incentives which will save the county money.
Sheriff Byam stated that negotiations for the
agreement have been on-going for several months, and that today some of
the final details were put into place. Sheriff Byam advised that
CrimeCog will provide the county with a special limited price which is
60 to 80 percent off the regular cost, plus there will no subscription
cost until 2007 if the county enters into the agreement by tomorrow.
Sheriff Byam further advised that other replacement software would be
much more costly. Sheriff Byam advised that CrimeCog shall prove all the
hardware, support, maintenance, and housing of the data.
Res. 117-2006
“Motion by Comr. Solis, supported by Comr. Moore,
adopt the following: Resolved by the Calhoun County Board of
Commissioners waive County Policy No. 405 - Purchasing to allow the
Sheriff Department to engage in final negotiations with CrimeCog
Technologies, Inc. for implementation of an E*Justice Information
System.”
Comr. Bolger disclosed that he has a conflict of
interest regarding this issue as his father was a co-founder of CrimeCog
Technologies, Inc., has stock ownership, and his immediate family would
benefit financially by this decision. Comr. Bolger advised that he
previously disclosed his conflict of interest to the Emergency Telephone
District Board, the Purchasing Division and Administration at the time
the issue was first discussed. Comr. Bolger advised that he shall
abstain from voting regarding this issue and on Item 10.A. (3), the
agreement.
| Roll call vote: |
Yes - 6 (Comrs. Segal, Solis,
Strowbridge, Todd, Miller and Moore) |
| |
Abstain - 1 (Comr. Bolger) |
Motion CARRIED
Criminal Justice Information System Agreement
Mr. Purcell stated that the agreement presented
represents approximately 18 months of investigation. Mr. Purcell advised
that the Albion City Police Department and the Marshall City Police
Department are already using this system; further, that Prosecutor
Hallacy uses the system as well.
Administrative Services Director Bradley Wilcox
advised that the Sheriff Department’s current FSG LEMS software was to
be the platform for an initiative by the Sheriff to host a countywide
centralized law enforcement information system which would facilitate
the sharing of criminal data by a number of public safety agencies
throughout Calhoun County; however approximately one year following the
initial implementation, the participating agencies decided to evaluate
other systems due to concerns regarding the functionality of LEMS. As
part of that search, a contingency of public safety officers attended an
on-site demonstration of the E*Justice system in Illinois and came back
with raving reviews. The Marshall City Police Department and the Albion
City Police Department signed an agreement with CrimeCog for the system
and discontinued their participation in the Sheriff’s system.
Mr. Wilcox continued that the Sheriff was faced with
the probability of replacing LEMS as FSG could not respond with
management changes and CrimeCog was considered as an option due to the
favorable reviews and the fact that Marshall and Albion are current
customers. Mr. Wilcox advised that in addition to the police departments
in Marshall and Albion, the Prosecutor is also connected to CrimeCog
through PAAM. Emmett Township’s Police Department and the Springfield
City Police Department are committed to implementation as soon as the
Sheriff Department “goes live,” and the Battle Creek City Police
Department is also considering CrimeCog.
Mr. Wilcox advised the CrimeCog’s system is fully
integrated to allow information sharing while maintaining data
ownership, autonomy, control with each agency, and can be integrated
with existing criminal justice systems. Mr. Wilcox stated that in order
to accomplish the Sheriff’s goal of a centralized criminal records
system, CrimeCog’s E*Justice system is the only platform capable of
linking all of the agencies. Mr. Wilcox pointed out that the E*Justice
system provides a significant opportunity to also implement an
integrated system with a single shared database for the Sheriff, the
Prosecutor’s Office, the courts and the Juvenile Home.
Mr. Wilcox advised that the evaluation team
identified a number of risks associated with implementing the system as
CrimeCog is a small company and the system is relatively untried,
therefore, Administrative Services hired Plante & Moran to perform an
independent viability analysis; and following a detailed investigation,
Plante & Moran’s suggestions were incorporated into the agreement. As a
contingency, the county has made arrangements to be recognized by
Northrup Gruman, that developed the system, as a paid customer in the
event CrimeCog is unable to fulfill their contractual obligations; also
the Sheriff owns the FSG-LEMS program code whereby it could be
implemented again if necessary.
Mr. Wilcox continued that one change within the
agreement is to provide, should the courts and the Juvenile Home decide
to “come on” this product, that the same pricing is available for a
period of 24 months. Mr. Wilcox addressed the budgeting implications,
advising that the non-reoccurring implementation cost totaling $70,000
shall be funded entirely by grants; e.g., Justice Assistance Grant,
Local Law Enforcement Block Grant, and MMRMA Risk Avoidance Grant. The
annual reoccurring subscription fees for the Sheriff Department would
not begin until April 2007 at $3,500 per month for 36 months, then
$4,250 per month for the 37th month through the 60th month, and $5,200
per month for months 60 through 72. The annual fees will be funded by
the Sheriff Department’s budget through savings from terminating the FSG
LEMS maintenance and reduced direct charges from the county Information
Technology Department. Mr. Wilcox advised that the net effect to the
General Fund is to shift those IT costs previously charged to the
Sheriff Department to other departments still using the AS400 such as
the courts, pointing out that increased cost to the Friend of the Court
will be state reimbursable. Mr. Wilcox estimated a net General Fund
impact of $16,000 for the first year and $26,000 annually in years two
and three. Mr. Wilcox recommended approval of the agreement.
Res. 118-2006
“Motion by Comr. Solis, supported by Comr. Moore,
adopt the following: Resolved by the Calhoun County Board of
Commissioners approve a six-year (6) Agreement between CrimeCog
Technologies, Inc. and Calhoun County in the total amount of $290,400
for the period of July 21, 2006 through July 21, 2013 to provide a
service bureau computer agreement for Northrup Gruman’s E*Justice
criminal justice information system (CJIS), as recommended by the
Administrative Services Director; further, authorize the Board
Chairman to execute said Agreement on behalf of Calhoun County.”
Comr. Strowbridge advised that in his day job he has
history with the system, and it is more user friendly than the LEM
system and is windows based. Comr. Strowbridge stated that the technical
support is immense, that CrimeCog addresses each and every problem
immediately and completely, and that there has been no problem that has
not been resolved. Comr. Strowbridge advised that the Albion Public
Safety Department’s E*Justice system went on-line this year and
CrimeCog’s technical support people spent the first 30 days with the
Department to service the Department’s accounts. Comr. Strowbridge
stated that he views going to this system as a tremendous opportunity to
integrate all of the justice systems within Calhoun County, and
encouraged the Board’s support.
Comr. Segal inquired whether the software shall be
constantly updated. Mr. Wilcox responded that there is a provision
within the agreement whereby enhancements to the system are required,
and advised as an example, that Administrative Services inquired
regarding integrating the Juvenile Home to acquire population statistics
and there is a module that can be adapted; however, CrimeCog developed a
module for that function.
Comr. Solis inquired whether the system shall create
savings in terms of man hours; i.e., staff reduction. Mr. Wilcox
responded that he cannot advise as that is not his area and that such a
number really should be determined by someone else. Mr. Wilcox stated
that the true efficiencies are that there will be an integrated system
for coordinating activities, eliminating redundant data entry and
improving the use of criminal information.
Comr. Solis inquired regarding Homer. Mr. Wilcox
advised that Homer has been approached and is interested in the product.
Mr. Wilcox stated that he believes that the others will be coming to the
system.
Chairman Miller stated that he has no doubt regarding
the potential of the E*Justice system. Chairman Miller inquired whether
CrimeCog shall bring a server on site. Mr. Wilcox responded Yes.
Comr. Segal inquired regarding cost should more
Calhoun County units come “on board.” Mr. Wilcox responded that a site
license was negotiated to cover that issue. The county will pay the same
price regardless of the number of users.
| Roll call vote: |
Yes - 6 (Comrs. Solis, Strowbridge,
Todd, Miller, Moore and Segal) |
| |
Abstain - 1 (Comr. Bolger) |
Motion CARRIED
CITIZENS’ TIME:
Mr. Berezonsky questioned violation of the county’s
purchasing policy, pointing out that the Administrative Services and
Sheriff Departments have been negotiating the E*Justice system agreement
for over a year.
Mr. Berezonsky inquired when the Sheriff Department
started providing private security. Mr. Berezonsky advised that an
officer in a patrol vehicle provided security on his property with no
contract. Mr. Berezonsky stated that he believes for the Sheriff
Department to be providing private security services is an inappropriate
use of taxpayers’ funds.
Mr. Berezonsky further inquired where the Sheriff
Department is keeping their boats, and whether the officers take the
boats home with them.
COMMISSIONERS’ TIME:
Comr. Moore reported that the Emmett Township
Planning Commission considered and unanimously approved the site plan
for the Medical Care Facility. Construction should commence on schedule.
Comr. Bolger congratulated the Sheriff and staff, and
Congressman Schwarz for the increase in the jail inmate boarding rate.
CLAIMS PAYABLE LISTINGS:
Res. 119-2006
“Motion by Comr. Bolger, supported by Comr. Solis,
adopt the following: Resolved by the Calhoun County Board of
Commissioners approve payment of the list of claims against the county
in the total amount of $299,889.42 for the week of July 5, 2006;
further, approve payment of the list of claims against the county in
the total amount of $757,314.91 for the week of July 11, 2006.”
Roll call vote: Yes - 7 Motion CARRIED Unanimously
CLOSED SESSION:
Res. 120-2006
“Motion by Comr. Bolger, supported by Comr. Solis,
adopt the following: Resolved by the Calhoun County Board of
Commissioners meet in Closed Session for the purpose of discussing
pending litigation with Corporation Counsel.”
Voice Vote: Motion CARRIED
The Board met in Closed Session commencing at 7:56
p.m. with Corporation Counsel Nancy Mullett, County
Administrator/Controller Greg Purcell, Sheriff Allen Byam and Deputy
Clerk Mary Lou Barrett present.
OPEN SESSION -- RECESS:
The Board returned to Open Session and recessed at
8:22 p.m. at the call of the Chair.
|