 |
Minutes Archive |
|
|
Board of
Commissioners Minutes
CALHOUN COUNTY
PROCEEDINGS OF THE
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
July 5, 2007
The Regular Session of the Calhoun County Board of Commissioners
convened at 7:02 p.m., Thursday, July 5, 2007 in the Commissioners
Meeting Room, Calhoun County Building, 315 West Green Street, Marshall,
Michigan.
Roll Call: Present: Comrs. Arnquist, Bolger, Segal,
Solis and Todd. Temporarily Excused: Comrs. Moore and Rae
(Arrived at 7:12 p.m.)
INVOCATION AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE:
A Moment of Silent Prayer was observed for Clerk Norlander’s Mother;
followed by the Pledge of Allegiance, led by Comr. Arnquist.
APPROVAL OF AGENDA/ADDENDUM:
“Motion by Comr. Solis, supported by Comr. Bolger, adopt the
following: Resolved by the Calhoun County Board of Commissioners
approve the July 5, 2007 agenda and addendum, as amended, to move Item
11.A. (2) - Request to Create and Fill an Electronic Archivist
Position to Item 6.A.”
Voice Vote: Motion CARRIED
ELECTED/APPOINTED COUNTY OFFICIALS’ COMMENTS:
Request to Create and Fill an Electronic Archivist Position
Clerk Anne Norlander thanked the Board for the moment of prayer for
her Mother.
Clerk Norlander requested the Board approve the position and allow
her to hire an electronic archivist. Clerk Norlander advised that the
Register of Deeds Office is developing an archival storage area for all
county departments and estimated that $37,000 to $40,000 could be saved
in off site storage fees. Clerk Norlander stated that since 1992 the
Clerk’s Office has transferred its court records to a storage site at
Fort Custer where it costs $20,000 a year in storage and retrieval
costs.
Clerk Norlander addressed improvements provided through the
Technology Fund; e.g., a public terminal in the lobby of the Circuit
Court Clerk’s Office, two scanners, a printer and three computers for
the archival area, twenty-nine flat screen monitors, shelving and
Register of Deeds records conversion. Clerk Norlander pointed out that
the 19 inch flat screen monitors replaced the 17 inch monitors, which
have been distributed to Mr. Wilcox to provide to other departments at
his discretion.
Clerk Norlander advised that the Technology Fund shall pay for the
position this year and then shall split the expense, with the General
Fund paying $20,000.
Res. 99-2007
“Motion by Comr. Moore, supported by Comr. Bolger, adopt the
following: Resolved by the Calhoun County Board of Commissioners grant
the Clerk-Register’s request to create and fill an Electronic
Archivist position to provide services to all county departments,
(Salary Grade D), with the entire cost of the position coming from the
Register of Deeds’ Technology Fund in 2007 and with future funding to
be split between the Technology Fund and the General Fund with the
General Fund contributing a maximum of $20,000 annually.”
Comr. Rae inquired how many years the position shall be funded. Clerk
Norlander responded “For perpetuity,” advising that the position is more
of a records maintenance position and estimated that conversion shall
take 15 to 20 years.
Comr. Solis stated that the position is to assist all county
departments, and questioned how that shall be accomplished. Clerk
Norlander advised that she has sent an email to each department to
acquire information regarding their records and that sometime this
Summer shall invite them to view the document system. Comr. Solis
inquired whether the Clerk’s Office utilizes a different system. Clerk
Norlander responded yes, however, advised that the vendor has stated
that the Clerk’s system is compatible with the other systems.
Comr. Solis addressed the $20,000 to be expended from the General
Fund, advising that as Chairman of the Budget Committee, without knowing
what the 2008 budget will look like, the position’s funding shall be
dependent upon what the budget numbers show.
Comr. Moore stated that he believes an archivist would provide for
greater efficiency and would perhaps save the taxpayers money. Comr.
Moore stated that he hopes that the other departments shall take
advantage of the position. Comr. Rae stated that he is pleased with the
proposal.
Comr. Arnquist noted the proposed salary, and advised that she is
aware of some high school graduates and some individuals with master
degrees that could do the work for that salary. Comr. Arnquist pointed
out that once the position is filled on a permanent basis, the county
shall have another employee, and requested the option of utilizing a
document storage/retrieval company be considered.
Clerk Norlander pointed out that each year there will be new
documents requiring imaging, and advised that just within the Clerk’s
Office there are boxes piled from the floor to the ceiling; further,
pointed out that the Probate Court has started imaging their records and
estimates it taking 15 to 20 years.
Comr. Arnquist stated that perhaps the Purchasing Division should put
out a request for proposals for a team to come in and perform the work
more quickly. Clerk Norlander stated that there will still be the need
for the other auxiliary services; further, pointed out that the salary
of $10.82 an hour is minuscule.
Comr. Arnquist inquired whether anyone has checked to determine the
expense of having a company handle the work. Clerk Norlander responded
that the departments do not even know what records are stored where.
Clerk Norlander stated that she believes the position is the smoothest
way to handle the imaging process.
County Administrator/Controller Greg Purcell stated that he believes
imaging is clearly the right way to go and concurred with the Clerk’s
proposal.
Comr. Todd inquired regarding the start date for the position. Mr.
Purcell responded that with the Board’s approval tonight, the Clerk can
request the Human Resource Department to post the position. Asst. County
Administrator Wendee Woods stated that the position shall be filled as
soon as possible, and that a person could start as early as two weeks.
Roll call vote: Yes - 7 Motion CARRIED Unanimously
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS:
Special Tribute to Mary Delamarter
Chairwoman Segal read, and accompanied by Senior Millage Allocation
Committee Chairman Solis, presented the following tribute to Ms.
Delamarter.
Res. 100-2007
“Motion by Comr. Bolger, supported by Comr. Solis, resolved by the
Calhoun County Board of Commissioners approve the following tribute:
The Calhoun County Senior Millage Allocation Committee and Board of
Commissioners wish to thank Mary for her years of service with the
Senior Millage Allocation Committee. Mary has served as a committee
member on the Senior Millage Allocation Committee since 2001.
During her service on the committee she has been a strong supporter
of services for seniors in Calhoun County that enable seniors to
remain in their homes. Mary thank you for:
- Always bringing forth the needs and concerns of seniors in your
community
- Always giving your expertise to The Senior Millage Allocation
Committee
- Always giving a well thought out response and strong leadership
- Serving on the Access Subcommittee
You have been a faithful volunteer, generously giving of your time
and knowledge to serve the senior citizens of Calhoun County. The
members of the Senior Millage Allocation Committee as well as the
Senior Citizens of Calhoun County have greatly benefitted from your
years of service.”
Voice Vote: Motion CARRIED
Ms. Delamarter stated that she has enjoyed serving on the Committee
and shall miss it.
FY 2006 County Audit Presentation
Mr. Purcell advised that the audit has been submitted to the state in
accordance with the end of June deadline.
Rehmann Robson Principal David Fisher advised that the Comprehensive
Annual Financial Report has been submitted to the Government Finance
Officers Association, and stated that he is confident that Calhoun
County shall receive the Certificate of Achievement for Excellence in
Financial Reporting again this year.
Mr. Fisher advised that the report reflects a clean opinion of the
county’s FY 2006 financial statements without exception or
qualifications. Mr. Fisher addressed the financial highlights listed
under Management’s Discussion and Analysis, advising that the assets of
the county exceeded its liabilities at the close of the year by $71.7
Million, of which $13.2 Million may be used to meet the county’s ongoing
obligations. The county’s total net assets increased by $6.4 Million
during 2006. Mr. Fisher further advised that the General Fund had an
increase to its fund balance of $961,835 for 2006; and that the
unreserved fund balance for the General Fund was $2,912,949 at the end
of the year, or approximately 9.45 percent of total General Fund
expenditures.
Mr. Purcell advised that the county has a policy of maintaining an
unreserved fund balance of 8 to 12 percent.
Mr. Fisher addressed the Revenue Sharing Reserve Fund summary,
advising that the fund balance is $9,767,852 which he anticipates shall
last until 2010; further, pointed out that the other governmental fund
balances have been increasing.
Mr. Fisher also addressed the Single Audit advising that there were
no questionable costs or any expenditures recommended for disallowance.
Mr. Fisher advised that total federal awards amounted to $6,666,250,
spent primarily by the Health Department and the Friend of the Court.
Mr. Fisher advised that within the Firm’s management letter is a
comment regarding use of credit cards. Mr. Fisher stated that the
county’s purchasing policy establishes guidelines for their use and that
it does not appear as though the credit cards currently be used were
issued under the policy and appear to have been issued without the
specific approval of the Board of Commissioners, as required by the
policy and state law. Mr. Fisher continued that the policy requires the
use of purchase orders for small purchases over $500, however, that
there were certain credit card purchases made in excess of $500 in
violation of the policy. Mr. Fisher further stated that the policy does
not currently address the timing of payments on credit card statements,
and that during the audit the Firm noted that credit cards were not
being paid in a timely manner and that finance charges, including
interest and late fees, were incurred. Mr. Fisher recommended the county
review its policy to ensure that it meets all state requirements and
that the policy is followed by all county departments. Mr. Fisher
advised that he is aware that the county intends to go to a purchasing
card system that shall have the necessary regulations in place.
Mr. Purcell advised that the Budget Committee has discussed the use
of purchase cards rather than credit cards, and that Mr. Wilcox is in
the process of acquiring those cards. Mr. Purcell stated that the credit
cards shall be rescinded and that this shall be accomplished prior to
the end of the year.
Comr. Rae asked Mr. Fisher whether it would be to the county’s
advantage to have a mid-year audit conducted. Mr. Fisher responded that
there would be additional expense for a mid-year audit, however, that a
mid-year audit would be very good as far as monitoring financial
results. Comr. Rae requested a cost estimate for conducting a mid-year
audit. Mr. Fisher responded “Approximately 50 to 75 percent of the
single audit cost, or $3,500.” Comr. Todd inquired whether the county
incurred any penalties for credit card purchases over $500. Mr. Purcell
responded no, however, advised that there were some late charges. Comr.
Solis advised that the purchasing cards are designed to limit what is
purchased and purchase amount limits can be established.
Mr. Purcell advised that a mid-year audit of the Clerk’s Office was
conducted this year, and that Administration has discussed with Rehmann
Robson the possibility of doing that elsewhere.
Comr. Solis addressed the parks deficit, stating that there are
concerns regarding how long the deficit should exist or whether there
should be a deficit elimination plan. Mr. Fisher advised that the
deficit has existed since 1999, and that the county filed a deficit
elimination plan with the state. Mr. Fisher stated that the plan needs
to be revisited because there has been an increase to that deficit for
the golf course operation.
Road Commission Managing Director Dennis Randolph stated that the
Road Commission got out of the golf course operation at the V.A. Mr.
Randolph advised that the Road Commission has been working to establish
a sticker program or gate fee program at the parks and is working on
some proposals to establish a fee schedule for next year. Mr. Randolph
further advised that the Road Commission shall also be having some funds
coming in from the Renaissance Faire and is “looking at growing” that
Faire. Mr. Randolph advised that he has a meeting July 18 with the
Administrator and shall be discussing some funds within another fund.
Mr. Randolph continued that the Road Commission is currently only
cutting the grass in the parks to keep the fund deficit from becoming
worse.
Comr. Solis inquired whether Mr. Randolph has any projections of how
long it will take to eliminate the deficit. Mr. Randolph responded that
it is contingent upon the discussion with Mr. Purcell on July 18.
Comr. Bolger stated that he would like to see a list of prohibited
purchases. Mr. Fisher advised that he can provide a listing of what is
allowed and what is not. Comr. Bolger requested that the Finance
Department and the Budget Committee provide a specific list of
prohibited purchases to the departments this year.
Comr. Moore inquired whether Mr. Fisher is aware of any counties that
partner to conduct internal audits. Mr. Fisher responded no, however,
advised that the schools are discussing sharing services.
Ms. Woods stated that Rehmann Robson was hired to review cash
receipting and reporting procedures for the Clerk’s Office, and advised
that the information shall be shared with all departments probably next
week.
Comr. Todd inquired whether the credit card late charges were
assessed to the departments. Mr. Purcell responded Yes.
Res. 101-2007
“Motion by Comr. Rae, supported by Comr. Solis, adopt the
following: Resolved by the Calhoun County Board of Commissioners
accept the Calhoun County Audit for the year ending December 31, 2006
as presented.”
Voice Vote: Motion CARRIED
Special Tribute to the United States Air Force Band of Flight
Chairwoman Segal advised that the tribute shall be presented to the
Band when the Band comes to Battle Creek Friday night for a performance.
Res. 102-2007
“Motion by Comr. Moore, supported by Comr. Todd, resolved by the
Calhoun County Board of Commissioners approve the following tribute:
WHEREAS, it is with great pleasure that we join with our fellow
citizens in welcoming the United States Air Force Band of Flight,
under the direction of Lieutenant Colonel Alan Sierichs, to Calhoun
County; and
WHEREAS, the Band of Flight is one of the oldest bands in the
United States Air Force, having been activated on September 24, 1942
at Patterson Field, OH - which later became Wright-Patterson AFB – as
the 361st Army Air Force Band. Over the years the band was
re-designated three times before becoming the Air Force Band of Flight
in 1991; and
WHEREAS, the purpose of the band is to support the global Air Force
mission in war and peace by fostering our national heritage and by
providing professional musical products and services for official
military, recruiting, and community relations events; and
WHEREAS, the Air Force Band of Flight and its various ensembles
perform a wide variety of music ranging from classical to rock, to
rhythm and blues and travel nearly 100,000 miles and perform over 500
times each year for military and civilian audiences throughout the
Midwest and eastern portions of the United States; and
WHEREAS, throughout its 65-year history the band has performed for
presidents, vice presidents, and numerous heads of state and has been
an integral part of numerous special events including the final
tribute to Michigan’s own President Gerald R. Ford as he was laid to
rest earlier this year in Grand Rapids; and
WHEREAS, in recognition of its contribution to our nation and to
the mission of the United States Air Force, the band of Flight has
been awarded four Air Force Outstanding Unit Award Citations, the Air
Force Organizational Excellence Award, and numerous civilian honors
including being chosen as a two-time recipient of the Colonel George
S. Howard Citation of Musical Excellence for Military Concert Bands
presented by the John Philip Sousa Foundation.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Calhoun County Board of
Commissioners is proud to welcome Lt. Col. Sierichs and the members of
the United States Air Force Band of Flight to Calhoun County and
applaud them for carrying on the finest traditions of the United
States Air Force and for serving as exemplary ambassadors of the
United States of America and its citizens.”
Voice Vote: Motion CARRIED
CONSENT AGENDA:
Chairwoman Segal addressed Item B.(3) - Road Commission Workshop
Creation/Appointments, advising that the Workshop shall review any
potential impacts of moving to a five-member Road Commission.
Comr. Moore inquired whether the Workshop is an extension of the Road
Commission Composition Workshop. Chairwoman Segal responded that the
Workshop is new.
Res. 103-2007
“Motion by Comr. Solis, supported by Comr. Arnquist, adopt the
following: Resolved by the Calhoun County Board of Commissioners
approve the following July 5, 2007 Consent Agenda as presented:
- Petitions, Communications, Reports:
| (1) |
Resolution received from Antrim
County supporting Senate Bill Nos. 410 and 411 {Emergency
Telephone Service Enabling Act Amendment}. (Referred to the
Legislative Liaisons, with a copy remitted to Emergency
Telephone District Board Chairman Allen Byam) |
| |
|
| (2) |
Resolutions received from Lake
County (1) urging the Federal Government to maintain current
federal funding and the Michigan legislature to hold counties
harmless for any losses as a result of legislative action, (2)
opposing House Bill No. 4398 {State Mandated Bidding of
Governmental Projects}, (3) urging the Michigan legislature to
freeze taxable values on residential properties, (4) supporting
Senate Bill Nos. 410 and 411 {Emergency Telephone Service
Enabling Act Amendment), and (5) supporting prepaid wireless
communication services and wireless 9-1-1 emergency service fees
and surcharges. (Referred to the Legislative Liaisons, with a
copy of (2) remitted to Administrative Services Director Bradley
Wilcox, a copy of (3) remitted to Equalization Director David
Jager, and a copy of (4 and 5) remitted to Emergency Telephone
District Board Chairman Allen Byam) |
| |
|
| (3) |
Notice of a public hearing
scheduled for June 19, 2007 regarding granting an Industrial
Facilities Exemption Certificate to EPI Printers, Inc. received
from Battle Creek City. (Received and placed on file, with a
copy remitted to Equalization Director David Jager) |
| |
|
| (4) |
Kalamazoo RESA Tax Levy
received from the Kalamazoo Regional Educational Service Agency.
(Received and placed on file, with a copy remitted to
Equalization Director David Jager) |
| |
|
| (5) |
FY 2005 Calhoun County Fiscal
Distress Indicators received from the Michigan Department of
Treasury. (Received and placed on file, with a copy remitted to
the Board of Commissioners) |
- Resolutions:
| (1) |
County of Calhoun Land
Bank Authority Board of Directors Appointment |
| |
(Term Expires November
30, 2008) |
| |
|
| |
{a} |
James Demarest (Replacing Ann
Armstrong) |
| |
|
| (2) |
Criminal Justice System
Workshop Appointments |
| |
(Terms Expire December
31, 2008) |
| |
|
| |
{a} |
Allen Garbrecht |
| |
{b} |
Kimberly Luther (Replacing Laraine
VanLopik) |
| |
{c} |
Greg Purcell |
| |
{d} |
Jeffrey Albaugh |
| |
{e} |
John Holmes |
| |
{f} |
Michelle Hill |
| |
{g} |
Trina McGaffigan |
| |
{h} |
Gary Reed |
| |
{i} |
Michael Boltz |
| |
{j} |
Allen Byam |
| |
{k} |
Marshall Weeks |
| |
{l} |
John Hallacy |
| |
|
| (3) |
Road Commission
Workshop Creation/Appointments |
| |
|
| |
{a} |
Eusebio Solis |
| |
{b} |
Jase Bolger |
| |
{c} |
Mike Rae” |
Voice Vote: Motion CARRIED
PETITIONS AND NEW BUSINESS:
County Administrator/Controller’s Report
Foreclosed Properties First Right of Refusal
Mr. Purcell advised that the county has the first right of refusal of
any properties remaining after the state, and there are no appropriate
properties which the county can use for public purposes.
Treasurer Ann Petredean stated that the right of refusal shall be an
annual item of business. Treasurer Petredean reported that this year
foreclosures were up by 600 properties, and that the Office foreclosed
on 25 more properties this year. Ms. Petredean advised that of the
foreclosures, 68 are vacant lots, 47 have buildings; and that of those
properties with buildings, approximately 37 are vacant. Ms. Petredean
stated that the Office does not know of those properties with people
living in them, how many are rental properties. Ms. Petredean advised
that 5 buildings will be demolished. Ms. Petredean reported that the
public auction of remaining properties shall be conducted September 5.
Ms. Petredean reported that the Harvard Industries property has
asbestos and chemical contamination, and the Environmental Protection
Agency (E.P.A.) has been in and Mr. Bartlett showed them Dalrymple
School which also has asbestos. The E.P.A. is submitting a grant
application to clean up both properties.
Res. 104-2007
“Motion by Comr. Rae, supported by Comr. Moore, resolved by the
Calhoun County Board of Commissioners adopt the following:
WHEREAS, Public Act 123 of 1999 changed the way delinquent taxes
are collected and disposed of, and has allowed County Treasurers to
administer the entire foreclosure process themselves; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Commissioners realize the importance that tax
reverted properties be disposed of in a coordinated manner that will
foster economic growth and eliminate blight within our communities;
and
WHEREAS, the Calhoun County Land Bank Authority has certain powers
and duties under the Land Bank Fast Track Act of 2003, of which
includes the ability to purchase certain properties from the County
Treasurer for the minimum bid amount so that it may remove these
properties from the auction process and dispose of them in a more
systematic process; and
WHEREAS, the County has a “First Right of Refusal” on any property
left over after the State of Michigan’s and the local units’ “First
Right of Refusal” and deems that no property could be used by the
County for public use.
THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the County declines all properties
left available that have been foreclosed upon by the Calhoun County
Treasurer and hereby grants the County’s “First Right of Refusal” to
the Calhoun County Land Bank Authority.”
Comr. Arnquist questioned the property with a minimum bid of
$769,152.22. Ms. Petredean advised that the property is Harvard
Industries which has 68 acres, a garage, and a park. Ms. Petredean
advised that the park shall be turned over to Albion City.
Roll call vote: Yes - 7 Motion CARRIED Unanimously
FY 2006-2007 Health Department Budget Adjustments
Mr. Purcell advised that the Board of Health approved the adjustments
at their June 18 meeting.
Health Officer Dottie-Kay Bowersox stated that the adjustments are
mainly “housekeeping” items to make sure the budget is in-line with
actual expenditures.
Res. 105-2007
“Motion by Comr. Rae, supported by Comr. Todd, adopt the following:
Resolved by the Calhoun County Board of Commissioners approve the FY
2006-2007 Health Department budget adjustments as recommended by the
Board of Health.”
Chairwoman Segal stated that the agenda information provided is
difficult to understand, and requested that future adjustments identify
the programs and explain why the adjustments are required.
Roll call vote: Yes - 7 Motion CARRIED Unanimously
CITIZENS’ TIME:
A representative of the Silver Leaf Renaissance Faire addressed the
parks deficit, advising that last year the Faire brought in $218,000 and
that every year the attendance increases. The representative advised
that two new events have been added and a campground is being built,
which shall be turned over to the Park Trustees.
The representative advised that May 2 Silver Leaf submitted its
development plan to the Road Commission, and offered to present the plan
to the Board and present the organization’s budget plan for the next
five years.
Mr. Gardy Berezonsky, Marengo Township resident, reported that the
Board of Health conducted a meeting at which he believes a quorum was
not present.
COMMISSIONERS’ TIME:
Chairwoman Segal announced that the Silver Leaf Renaissance Faire
“kicks off” this week in Kimball Pines Park.
CLAIMS PAYABLE LISTINGS:
Res. 106-2007
“Motion by Comr. Rae, supported by Comr. Todd, adopt the following:
Resolved by the Calhoun County Board of Commissioners approve payment
of the list of claims against the county in the total amount of
$311,288.87 for the week of June 19, 2007; further, approve payment of
the list of claims against the county in the total amount of
$900,435.45 for the week of June 26, 2007.”
Roll call vote: Yes - 7 Motion CARRIED Unanimously
ADJOURNMENT:
The meeting adjourned at 8:44 p.m. at the call of the Chair.
|